VB-MAPP domain

Echoic in ABA: what it is and why it comes before mand training

An echoic in ABA is a vocal response that copies what another person just said: the adult says “car,” the child says “car.” Echoics matter less for their own sake than as the prompt that teaches every other spoken skill, which is why the VB-MAPP measures them at Levels 1 and 2 and why most programs teach them before and during mand training.

By Ab Advany, founder of SuperChild · Published

VB-MAPP levels
2
Milestone areas
4
Practice goals
12
SuperChild trainings
0

What is an echoic in ABA?

An echoic is a spoken response that matches the sound of a spoken model and is reinforced by the match itself or by praise. It has point-to-point correspondence with the model: the child’s word copies the adult’s word sound by sound.

Skinner grouped the echoic with the other verbal operants because it is learned and controlled by another person’s speech, the same way a mand is controlled by motivation and a tact by something in view. What sets it apart is the formal match. The child hears “ba” and says “ba,” hears “banana” and says “nana,” then later “banana.” A child who repeats you is not yet using the word to ask for or name anything, and that is fine. The echoic is the raw material.

The practical value is the prompt. Once a child will repeat on request, you can give any new word as a model, get it said in the right situation, and fade the model. That is how most vocal mands, tacts and intraverbals are taught. A child with no echoic repertoire has to learn every word some slower way, which is why speech-focused programs check echoic skills early and why many children start manding with signs or pictures while their echoics develop.

Echoic behavior is different from echolalia, though they look alike. Echolalia is repetition that is not under the control of a useful context, such as repeating a whole TV script or the last line of a question instead of answering it. An echoic taught in ABA is brief, follows a model on purpose, and is then transferred to other operants.

  • Counts as echoic

    The adult says “Say moo” during a farm-animal song

    The child says “moo”

    The spoken model set off a matching vocal response. A clear echoic aba example.

  • Counts as echoic

    The adult says “ball” and the child says “ba”

    An approximation of the first syllable

    Early echoics are scored by closeness to the model. Reinforce the best approximation and shape toward the full word.

  • Not echoic

    The adult asks “Do you want juice?”

    The child says “want juice” and does not drink when given it

    This is echolalia. The child repeated part of a question instead of answering it, and the words did not work as a request.

  • Counts as echoic

    The adult says “Say ball” while holding a ball out of reach; the child repeats “ball” and gets it

    A prompted mand

    The response is still an echoic because the model controlled it, but it is the first step of an echoic to mand transfer. Fade the model next.

  • Not echoic

    The child sees the ball and says “ball” with no model

    Gets the ball

    No spoken model was involved, so this is a mand. The transfer has worked.

  • Not echoic

    The adult claps twice and the child claps twice

    A copied action

    Copying a movement is motor imitation, a separate VB-MAPP domain. Echoics are vocal only.

What the child does, and whether it counts, decides how you score and teach it.

Echoic milestones, goals and activities by level

Each milestone area below is our own summary of a group of VB-MAPP milestones, with measurable practice goals, everyday activities and the sign that a learner is ready for the next step. Score the official protocol first; then use the area that matches.

Level 1 · 0–18 months

At Level 1 the child repeats sounds and syllables they already babble, then new syllable combinations and first short words, with approximations counted as progress.

  • Milestones 1–3

    Repeating early sounds and syllables

    The child repeats simple sounds and syllables after an adult, starting with sounds they already make on their own.

    Practice goals

    1. Repeats 5 different vowel or consonant-vowel sounds (ma, ba, ee) after a model on 4 of 5 trials.
    2. Repeats an adult’s sound within 3 seconds on 80% of trials across 2 sessions.
    3. Repeats sounds with 2 different adults during play routines.

    Everyday activities

    • Sit face to face and copy the child’s own babbles, then pause for them to copy you back.
    • Use animal sounds in a farm game: “the cow says moo”, then pause.
    • Echoic practice stays with the team (BCBA or SLP); use songs and toys with clear, short sounds to keep it fun.

    Ready to move on: Ready when the child repeats new sounds quickly and willingly with more than one adult.

    Open in the goal mapper
  • Milestones 4–5

    Repeating syllable combinations and first words

    The child repeats combinations of different syllables and short words, with closer and closer pronunciation.

    Practice goals

    1. Repeats 10 two-syllable combinations (“ba-da”, “mama”) after a model on 80% of trials.
    2. Repeats 10 simple words with a recognizable approximation on 4 of 5 trials.
    3. Repeats words during natural routines (snack, bath) at least 5 times per session.

    Everyday activities

    • Name each snack piece with a short word and pause for the child to say it before handing it over.
    • Play with toy cars and say “go” and “stop”, waiting for the child to repeat each.
    • Echoic practice stays with the team; pair repetitions with requests the child is motivated for.

    Ready to move on: Look for word repetitions that turn into requests and labels without a model.

    Open in the goal mapper

Level 2 · 18–30 months

At Level 2 the child repeats longer words and short phrases more clearly, and starts to copy how something is said (loud or soft, fast or slow, a rising tone), not only the words.

  • Milestones 6–8

    Repeating longer words and short phrases

    The child repeats multi-syllable words and short phrases more clearly.

    Practice goals

    1. Repeats 15 multi-syllable words (banana, elephant) with a recognizable approximation on 80% of trials.
    2. Repeats 2- and 3-word phrases after a model on 4 of 5 trials.
    3. Repeats new words immediately during book reading at least 5 times per session.

    Everyday activities

    • Read a repetitive picture book and pause for the child to repeat the repeating line.
    • Use a toy microphone and take turns saying short phrases like “I see a dog.”
    • Echoic practice stays with the team, often together with an SLP for sound accuracy.

    Ready to move on: Ready when the child repeats new words and phrases accurately without many tries.

    Open in the goal mapper
  • Milestones 9–10

    Copying rhythm, loudness and speed

    The child copies how something is said (loud or soft, fast or slow, rising tone) as well as the words themselves.

    Practice goals

    1. Repeats a phrase in a loud and a quiet voice after a model on 4 of 5 trials.
    2. Copies a fast or slow rhythm in a chant on 80% of trials.
    3. Repeats new phrases from songs with matching intonation on 3 occasions.

    Everyday activities

    • Play “big voice, tiny voice” with a toy bear and a toy mouse.
    • Chant nursery rhymes with claps, changing speed and loudness.
    • Echoic and voice work stays with the team; songs and chants make practice natural.

    Ready to move on: Look for natural-sounding speech in everyday talk, not only when copying.

    Open in the goal mapper

How to teach echoics and transfer them to mands

Echoic training works best in short, playful bursts, often inside routines the child already enjoys. The last two steps cover the echoic to mand transfer, which is where the skill earns its keep.

  1. 1Start with sounds the child already makesListen for 15 minutes of play and write down every sound the child produces. Your first echoic targets are those sounds. Pair your voice with fun: make the sound during tickles, swings and bubbles so that hearing it, and making it, becomes reinforcing.
  2. 2Model, wait, reinforce any attemptSay the target once, clearly, and wait a few seconds. Reinforce any vocal attempt at first, then only responses that get closer to the model. Keep demands light; echoic training stalls fast if the child starts to avoid it.
  3. 3Build from sounds to syllables to wordsMove from single sounds (“ah,” “mm”) to consonant-vowel syllables (“ba,” “ma”), to repeated syllables (“baba”), to two different syllables and then to short words. Shaping in small steps keeps the success rate high.
  4. 4Use the echoic as a mand promptWhen the child wants an item, say its name and give the item when the child repeats it. This is why echoics are taught before and during mand training: the model gets the word said at the exact moment motivation is high, so the item can reinforce it.
  5. 5Fade the model with a time delayOn later trials, wait before giving the model. When the child says the word first, give a bigger reinforcer. Partial models (just the first sound, “b...”) help in between. The echoic to mand transfer is complete when the word happens with no model at all.

Common mistakes, and what to do instead

Drilling echoics as a stand-alone program
A child who only repeats on command has a skill with no use. Tie echoic practice to mands and tacts within the same session.
Reinforcing echolalia
Repeating the question instead of answering it can be accidentally reinforced if the adult hands over the item anyway. Model the answer, not the question, and reinforce the answer.
Pushing for perfect articulation
Correcting every sound makes vocal practice aversive. Accept approximations and bring in a speech-language pathologist when sounds do not progress.
Waiting for echoics before teaching any communication
A child without echoics still needs a way to request. Start signs or picture exchange in parallel; they do not block speech.

How to measure echoic progress

Score each echoic trial as exact, approximation or no response, and graph the percentage of exact matches per target over sessions. The ABA data sheets include a trial-by-trial sheet you can use for this.

How it connects to the other domains

  • Mand

    Echoics give mand training its main prompt, and the model is faded until the request stands on its own.

  • Tact

    New labels usually start as echoics of the adult’s word in front of the item, then transfer to the item alone.

  • Spontaneous vocal behavior

    Spontaneous babbling supplies the first sounds to echo, so the two domains grow together at Level 1.

  • Motor imitation

    Copying actions often comes in before copying sounds and can be used to build the general habit of imitating.

Printables and tools to practise with

Independent guide by SuperChild, not affiliated with the publisher or authors. Use the official protocol to administer and score.

Written from the publishers’ own materials and published research. Spotted an error? Email contact@superchild.ai and we’ll fix it.

FAQ

Questions teams and parents ask

What is echoic in ABA?
An echoic is repeating what someone else just said, such as saying “cup” right after the adult says “cup.” In ABA it is one of Skinner’s verbal operants and is used mainly as a prompt for teaching requests, labels and answers.
Echoics are taught before and during mand training because what?
Echoics are taught before and during mand training because a child who can repeat a spoken model can be prompted to say the name of an item at the moment they want it. The item then reinforces the word, and the model is faded until the child requests on their own. Without echoics, vocal mands are very hard to prompt.
What is an echoic to mand transfer?
It is the procedure of moving a word from the echoic to the mand. The adult models the word while the child wants the item, delivers the item when the child repeats it, and then delays or shortens the model over trials until motivation alone sets the word off.
What is an echoic ABA example?
During a bubbles game the therapist says “pop” and the child says “pop.” Another example is the therapist saying “ba” and the child answering “ba” in a sound-play routine. Both are echoics because the child’s response copies the spoken model.
Is an echoic the same as echolalia?
No. An echoic is a brief, purposeful repetition that is used to teach other skills. Echolalia is repetition of words or scripts outside a useful context, such as repeating a question instead of answering it. Teams often work on reducing echolalia by teaching the correct answer as the model.
Does the VB-MAPP test echoics at Level 3?
No. In the VB-MAPP the echoic domain covers Levels 1 and 2. Many teams use the Early Echoic Skills Assessment that comes with the protocol for a more detailed look at early vocal imitation.

Next step

Bring a learner’s VB-MAPP. We’ll show the daily practice.

See how SuperChild turns the milestones a professional picks into short practice sessions a young child does independently, with every trial recorded.